PDM Solutions: Moving from Excel, How and Why?

Blog • PLM & PDM

As an engineer or product manager, Excel has likely been your go-to for storing, organizing, and sharing product data. Its power and versatility in handling vast amounts of data and complex calculations are well-known. Yet, Excel shows its limitations when managing engineering data, particularly as project complexity and scale increase.

In this discussion, we’ll delve into the challenges of relying on Excel for product data management (PDM) and illustrate why PDM solutions offer a more capable alternative. Additionally, we’ll guide you through a straightforward process for transitioning your data from Excel to a PDM solution, ensuring a smoother, more efficient management of your product data.

Product Data Management (PDM) encompasses the entire process of capturing, storing, organizing, and managing product-related data, including design specifications, drawings, models, bills of materials, documents, revisions, and workflows. PDM is a critical tool for engineering teams, enhancing collaboration, communication, and coordination in a highly effective and efficient manner.

PDM solutions serve as a centralized, secure repository for all product data, enabling users to easily access, edit, and share information with team members and stakeholders. Furthermore, it automates and optimizes data management tasks such as version control, change management, approval processes, and reporting, making it an indispensable asset for streamlined project execution.

Although Excel excels in data analysis and manipulation, it falls short when it comes to product data management. Here are the key reasons Excel isn’t the best fit for PDM Solutions:

• Insufficient Security Measures

Excel’s ease of copying, modifying, and deleting files poses significant risks, including data loss, corruption, and unauthorized access. Without an audit trail or version history, tracking and resolving changes becomes challenging. Additionally, Excel’s lack of support for encryption or password protection further jeopardizes data privacy and security.

• Challenges in Collaboration and Communication

Excel struggles with allowing multiple users to edit and share files simultaneously, leading to potential conflicts and errors. Without features for real-time collaboration or notifications, Excel makes it difficult to maintain effective communication and coordination. Additionally, its limited integration with other essential tools like CAD (computer-aided design), ERP (enterprise resource planning), and cloud services restricts data accessibility and interoperability, creating barriers to seamless collaboration.

• Challenges with Scalability and Performance

As product data expands, Excel files often grow unwieldy, slowing down systems and hindering productivity. Without support for data validation or quality checks, Excel fails to prevent inaccuracies or inconsistencies. Furthermore, the absence of automation and optimization features, like workflows, rules, or templates, means missing out on opportunities to streamline processes and save time and effort.

Benefits of Using PDM Solutions Over Excel for Product Data Management, include:

• Improved Security and Management

PDM Solutions elevates the security and management of your product data by enabling customizable permissions, roles, and access levels for various users and groups. They bolster data privacy and security through encryption and password protection features. Furthermore, PDM solutions provide a comprehensive audit trail and version history for all data modifications and activities, facilitating more effective design change management and issue resolution.

• Enhanced Teamwork and Connectivity

A PDM solution enables you to share and update product data with your team and stakeholders seamlessly in real-time. With built-in collaboration and communication tools like comments, chats, alerts, and reminders, PDM solutions foster a connected working environment. They also enhance data accessibility and compatibility by smoothly integrating with other essential software and platforms, including CAD, ERP, and cloud services, ensuring your team stays in sync and productive.

• Boosted Scalability and Efficiency

PDM Solutions effortlessly manages large and complex sets of product data, maintaining high speed and performance without a hitch. They ensure the consistency and accuracy of data through robust data validation and quality checks. Moreover, PDM Solutions like Windchill come equipped with automation and optimization capabilities, including prebuilt templates and workflows, significantly reducing the time and effort required for data management tasks.

• PDM Solutions as a Service

PDM Solutions are now available through software-as-a-service (SaaS) models, such as Windchill+. This SaaS version of Windchill offers rapid updates and new functionalities, meeting user expectations efficiently. These SaaS deployments provide all the aforementioned benefits of PDM solutions—enhanced accessibility and security, improved collaboration, and greater scalability—thus maximizing their effectiveness and impact.

Using PDM Solutions for product data management offers numerous advantages over Excel. If you’re currently managing your product data with Excel, you might wonder about the process for transitioning this data to a PDM solution.

• Get Your Data Ready

Before shifting your data to a PDM solution, it’s crucial to get it in the right shape for the move. This involves cleaning, organizing, and standardizing your data, as well as eliminating duplicates, errors, or any inconsistencies. Additionally, you’ll need to outline your data structure—identifying fields, attributes, and relationships—and align them with the equivalent components for a PDM solution.

• Select the Right PDM Solution

The next step is selecting a PDM solution that aligns with your specific requirements and preferences. The market offers a variety of PDM solutions, each boasting unique features, functionalities, and pricing structures. Take the time to compare and assess these options to identify the most suitable choice for your business. It’s also important to ensure that your chosen PDM solution integrates well with any current tools and platforms you use, like CAD, ERP, or cloud services.

• Transfer Your Data to the PDM Solution

After choosing your PDM solution, the next step is to move your data from Excel. This process can be manual or automatic, based on your chosen PDM solution and the format of your data. Many PDM solutions provide detailed guides or have integrated import tools to assist you through this phase. In some cases, you might need to use additional tools or scripts. Make sure to adhere to the PDM solution’s guidelines and requirements to guarantee a smooth and accurate data transfer.

• Check Your Data Accuracy

Once your data is imported into the PDM solution, it’s crucial to confirm its accuracy. Look for any mistakes, inconsistencies, or gaps in the data and address these issues promptly. Additionally, it’s important to test and confirm the functionality and performance of your data—such as calculations, workflows, and reports—to make sure everything operates smoothly and as anticipated.

• Educate Your Team

Finally, ensure your team is well-versed in using the PDM solution and its functionalities. Offer comprehensive documentation, tutorials, and support to aid their learning process and help them adapt to the new system comfortably. Additionally, gathering feedback and suggestions from users is a best practice, as it allows you to identify and resolve any issues or concerns they may encounter.

Transitioning from Excel to a PDM solution represents a strategic upgrade for engineering teams, offering a pathway to more effective and secure product data management, enhanced team collaboration, and scalable, efficient performance handling. By adhering to outlined steps and best practices for data migration, the move from Excel to a PDM solution, such as Windchill+, becomes straightforward.

This shift not only helps overcome the limitations of legacy systems but also embraces the advantages of the latest PDM solutions delivered through SaaS. It paves the way for future advancements in Product Lifecycle Management (PLM). Embrace the transition to a PDM solution for swift implementation, immediate value realization, and adherence to industry-leading practices. Start your journey towards a seamless Excel to PDM transition today.

Download the PDM buyer’s guide from analyst firm Tech-Clarity to help identify the right PDM solution for your organization!

TriStar PLM Solutions welcomes questions. Feel free to CONTACT US if you can’t find what you’re looking for, or call us at 800-800-1714